By Kyle Clifford Knapp - November 3, 2026
|
|
|
Coinage of Brutus from the Tyrant Collection.
Click image to enlarge.
|
Examining and certifying coins from
the famed Tyrant Collection has been an
unrivaled privilege for PCGS experts over
the past year. Somewhat astonishingly,
the display at the recent American
Numismatic Association World’s Fair of
Money in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, was
but one tranche of a wide-ranging and
comprehensive collection of historically
and conditionally significant pieces
illustrating humanity’s long and difficult
struggle with the distribution, moderation,
and transfer of political power.
Two exceptional and famous pieces from
the collection demonstrate the enduring
resonance of coinage as a propaganda
mechanism and offer a tangible link
to the fateful final years of the Roman
Republic. The Casca aureus and Eid Mar
denarius of Brutus are not only among the
most recognizable and valuable ancient
coins, but they are also of the class of
numismatic issues most inextricably linked
to transformative historical events in terms
of design.
Marcus Junius Brutus is a name today
often associated with betrayal, treachery,
and violence. A more thorough look into
the life of Caesar’s most famous assassin
offers a more layered, nuanced portrait.
(Our) Brutus was a direct descendant
of Lucius Junius Brutus, long revered as
the leader of the revolt which overthrew
Tarquin the Proud and put an end to over
200 years of elective monarchy, ushering in
the Republican period, during which the
moderation and containment of absolute
power would become both a central
political goal and vexing logistical problem.
Brutus is likely to have taken great pride
in this familial legacy of liberation as he
navigated the quickly changing world of
the late republic nearly five centuries later.
After a long and impressive consolidation
of power, Julius Caesar was proclaimed
dictator perpetuo (“in perpetuity”) in
January or February of 44 BCE. Fear of
a return to the reviled days of unilateral
rule gave rise to graffiti throughout the
capital urging Brutus to assume the
historical mantle of his gens. Ultimately,
he would indeed become one of the dozens
of tyrannical figures who conspired to
fatally attack Caesar on the Ides of March,
initiating a chain of events that reshaped
Rome and much of the Western world.
|
|
|
42 BC - AV Aureus Roman Republic Brutus & Casca Longus - Tyrant, PCGS MS64
Click image to enlarge.
|
Perhaps aiming to defend the act as one of
deliberative political necessity rather than
gratuitous violence, Brutus attempted to
address the senate, but the commotion had
been too much; his words were not heard.
The negotiated settlement following the
assassination provided for a funeral for
Caesar at which Mark Antony’s eloquent
oration definitively turned public opinion
against the Liberatores (as the conspirators
deemed themselves). Tensions would
escalate throughout the summer,
eventually blossoming into a civil war that
would find Brutus and ally Cassius pitted
against Antony and Octavian. It was during
these monumental battles in Asia Minor
the military mints accompanying Brutus
would strike the infamous coins pictured
here during the fall of 42 BCE.
Each features an obverse portrait of
Brutus – in “baroque” style on the gold
aureus and “realistic” style on the silver
denarius. Portraiture of this kind was
atypical of Brutus’s coinage and may have
been a last resort to rouse political favor
as his battlefield outlook bleakened. The
reverse of the denarius is perhaps the most
well-known and coveted design in all of
numismatics, commemorating the Ides of
March with a pileus between two daggers.
Both are extraordinarily rare: 17 Casca
aurei are traced today, along with perhaps
a hundred Eid Mar denarii. Shortly after
their issue, Brutus – knowing the battle was
lost – would take his own life with the same
dagger which had impaled Ceasar.
The raw violence of the act, the numismatic
glorification of the weapon, the personal
closeness of perpetrator and victim; these
facts can trace a reprehensible sketch. The
counternarrative, however, is encapsulated
by the central element of the Eid Mar die: the
pileus. Used in manumission ceremonies
and broadly regarded as emblematic of
liberty and personal freedom, Brutus
no doubt sought to frame his actions
as those of one defending the republic.
Supporting this interpretation is the careful
construction of the act itself: not in a dark
alley by anonymous criminals, but in an
official place by dozens of high-ranking
members of society making no effort
to conceal their identities. It was in fact
Brutus who vetoed the idea of assassinating
Mark Antony along with Caesar, and who
agreed to the settlement permitting a
public funeral in honor of the deceased.
Whatever side one falls upon, the events
of 44-42 BCE, transported from that time
to the present so simply and beautifully on
these two coins, gave centuries of life to the
debate over when violence is permissible to
check political power and how, if deemed
necessary, it should be carried out.
The Roman Republic would not survive
the turmoil following Caesar’s assassination
and the subsequent civil wars. Brutus’s act
– justified or contrived, heroic or evil –
brought about the end of one of the most
studied periods of human civilization and
ushered in another. The Roman Empire
was about to begin.
Article provided by PCGS at www.pcgs.com